Brain Lab

{
  "readiness": {
    "beforeConfirmation": {
      "readyForSummary": true,
      "readyForOutputs": false,
      "needsFollowUpBeforeVision": true
    },
    "afterConfirmation": {
      "readyForOutputs": true
    }
  },
  "extractedIngredients": {
    "productName": "",
    "parentProductFamily": "",
    "productCategory": "portable digital reading device",
    "primaryCustomer": "readers",
    "primaryUser": "readers",
    "economicBuyer": "readers",
    "endBeneficiary": "readers",
    "supplySideParticipant": "publishers and authors",
    "gatekeeperOrCriticalDependency": "",
    "ecosystemPartner": "publishers and authors",
    "problem": "Physical books are bulky, delivery takes time and readers cannot carry a whole library with them.",
    "currentAlternative": "physical books",
    "currentAlternativeFailure": "They are not instantly portable or available wherever the reader is.",
    "desiredFutureState": "portable device for digital books",
    "visionCandidate": "Every reader can access any book instantly, anywhere.",
    "positioningCandidate": "",
    "productDescriptionCandidate": "A portable device for reading and carrying digital books.",
    "strategicBet": "Readers will change behaviour if access to books becomes instant and portable.",
    "hardToCopyAdvantage": "A connected reading device, digital library and publishing ecosystem.",
    "evidenceNeeded": [
      "reader adoption",
      "publisher participation",
      "content availability"
    ],
    "unknowns": [
      "product name",
      "pricing model",
      "technical implementation"
    ],
    "_rawInput": "We are building a portable device for reading digital books. Physical books are bulky, delivery takes time and people cannot easily carry a whole library with them. Readers want instant access to books wherever they are. Publishers and authors need a better way to reach readers digitally.",
    "inputQuality": "serious",
    "shouldUseForLearning": true,
    "shouldProceed": true,
    "isProductRelevant": true,
    "promptInjectionBlocked": false,
    "endCustomerOrBeneficiary": "",
    "rawVisionCandidate": "Digital books become portable and instantly accessible.",
    "sharpenedVisionCandidate": "Every reader can access any book instantly, anywhere.",
    "recommendedNextQuestion": "Is the bigger future that every reader can access any book instantly, anywhere?",
    "visionModeSystemNote": "Technical, commercial, naming, delivery and derived-output unknowns were saved for later and not used as Vision Brain follow-up questions.",
    "unknownClassification": {
      "visionCritical": [],
      "strategyCritical": [],
      "credibilityCritical": [],
      "optionalNamingLater": [
        "product name"
      ],
      "commercialLater": [
        "pricing model"
      ],
      "technicalLater": [
        "technical implementation"
      ],
      "deliveryLater": [],
      "derivedLater": []
    },
    "readyForSummary": true,
    "readyForOutputs": false,
    "needsFollowUpBeforeVision": true
  },
  "outputs": {
    "vision": "Every reader can access any book instantly, anywhere.",
    "positioning": "For readers who want books without carrying or waiting for physical copies, the product provides a portable digital reading experience connected to a broad book catalogue.",
    "productDescription": "A portable reading device and digital book platform for buying, downloading and reading books.",
    "strategicBet": "Reading becomes more frequent and accessible when books can be discovered, bought and opened instantly.",
    "evidenceNeeded": [
      "Readers can move from book discovery to reading in minutes",
      "A broad catalogue of high-demand titles is available digitally",
      "Readers repeatedly buy, download and read books on the device",
      "Publishers make meaningful catalogue inventory available",
      "Users substitute some physical book purchases with digital reading"
    ]
  },
  "failures": [],
  "judge": {
    "judgeName": "Judge Judy",
    "judgeVersion": "judge-judy-v0.1",
    "overallScore": 100,
    "scores": {
      "visionQuality": 100,
      "visionNotPositioning": 100,
      "stakeholderSeparation": 100,
      "followUpQuestionQuality": 100,
      "readinessGateCorrectness": 100,
      "evidenceSpecificity": 100,
      "outputSeparation": 100,
      "avoidsRabbitHoles": 100,
      "stopCondition": 100
    },
    "stageScores": {
      "extractionQuality": 50,
      "visionShapingQuality": 100,
      "followUpQuality": 100,
      "readinessGateQuality": 100,
      "guardrailQuality": 100,
      "outputQuality": 100,
      "traceQuality": 100
    },
    "correctionsMade": [
      {
        "component": "Supernanny",
        "correction": "Promoted product-object raw candidate into user/world outcome vision candidate."
      },
      {
        "component": "Homer Simpson",
        "correction": "Turned generic extracted evidence into observable proof points in generated outputs."
      },
      {
        "component": "Homer Simpson",
        "correction": "Generated usable positioning from thin or missing extracted positioning candidate."
      },
      {
        "component": "Arnold J. Rimmer",
        "correction": "Saved later-mode technical or commercial unknowns instead of letting them drive Vision mode follow-up."
      },
      {
        "component": "The Rock",
        "correction": "Applied summary/output readiness gates and stopped follow-up mining once outputs were ready."
      }
    ],
    "passType": "pass_with_corrections",
    "failures": [],
    "verdict": "Excellent. Strong, precise, strategic and free of material issues.",
    "whyNot100": "",
    "scoreExplanation": "Excellent final output. Supernanny corrected a product-object raw vision candidate into a stronger user/world outcome. The raw desired future state was weak or product-like, but the sharpened candidate carried the final vision work. Louis Theroux used the sharpened future-state candidate in the confirmation question. Homer Simpson turned generic extracted evidence into more observable proof points in the generated outputs. Homer Simpson generated usable positioning from ingredients even though the extracted positioning candidate was thin or missing. Arnold J. Rimmer kept Vision mode out of pricing, API and implementation rabbit holes.",
    "qualityNotes": [
      "Supernanny corrected a product-object raw vision candidate into a stronger user/world outcome.",
      "The raw desired future state was weak or product-like, but the sharpened candidate carried the final vision work.",
      "Louis Theroux used the sharpened future-state candidate in the confirmation question.",
      "Homer Simpson turned generic extracted evidence into more observable proof points in the generated outputs.",
      "Homer Simpson generated usable positioning from ingredients even though the extracted positioning candidate was thin or missing.",
      "Arnold J. Rimmer kept Vision mode out of pricing, API and implementation rabbit holes."
    ],
    "recommendedBrainImprovement": "No immediate Brain improvement recommended for this case."
  },
  "passType": "pass_with_corrections",
  "stageScores": {
    "extractionQuality": 50,
    "visionShapingQuality": 100,
    "followUpQuality": 100,
    "readinessGateQuality": 100,
    "guardrailQuality": 100,
    "outputQuality": 100,
    "traceQuality": 100
  },
  "correctionsMade": [
    {
      "component": "Supernanny",
      "correction": "Promoted product-object raw candidate into user/world outcome vision candidate."
    },
    {
      "component": "Homer Simpson",
      "correction": "Turned generic extracted evidence into observable proof points in generated outputs."
    },
    {
      "component": "Homer Simpson",
      "correction": "Generated usable positioning from thin or missing extracted positioning candidate."
    },
    {
      "component": "Arnold J. Rimmer",
      "correction": "Saved later-mode technical or commercial unknowns instead of letting them drive Vision mode follow-up."
    },
    {
      "component": "The Rock",
      "correction": "Applied summary/output readiness gates and stopped follow-up mining once outputs were ready."
    }
  ],
  "judgeName": "Judge Judy",
  "judgeVersion": "judge-judy-v0.1",
  "systemDesignVersion": "system-design-v0.8",
  "suggestedFix": "No immediate Brain improvement recommended for this case.",
  "trace": {
    "brainVersion": "vision-brain-v0.1",
    "promptVersion": "vision-prompts-v0.1",
    "schemaVersion": "strategy-schema-v0.1",
    "judgeName": "Judge Judy",
    "judgeVersion": "judge-judy-v0.1",
    "systemDesignVersion": "system-design-v0.8",
    "traceRecorder": {
      "formalName": "Trace Recorder",
      "internalName": "C-3PO",
      "responsibility": "Records prompts, payloads, responses, adjustments, usage and versions"
    },
    "caseAndReportStore": {
      "formalName": "Case & Report Store",
      "internalName": "Gollum",
      "responsibility": "Stores golden cases, eval reports, traces and precious examples"
    },
    "extractionAdjustments": [
      {
        "field": "unknownClassification",
        "adjustedValue": {
          "visionCritical": [],
          "strategyCritical": [],
          "credibilityCritical": [],
          "optionalNamingLater": [
            "product name"
          ],
          "commercialLater": [
            "pricing model"
          ],
          "technicalLater": [
            "technical implementation"
          ],
          "deliveryLater": [],
          "derivedLater": []
        },
        "reason": "Unknowns are bucketed by whether they affect Vision mode now or later.",
        "ruleApplied": "classify unknowns by Vision mode priority",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Mode & Safety Rules",
          "internalName": "Arnold J. Rimmer",
          "responsibility": "Blocks premature pricing, API, technical and mode-breaking rabbit holes"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "visionCandidate",
        "originalValue": "",
        "adjustedValue": "Digital books become portable and instantly accessible.",
        "reason": "Vision mode needs a concise future-state candidate, not a raw product description.",
        "ruleApplied": "elevate raw future state into vision candidate",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Vision Shaper",
          "internalName": "Supernanny",
          "responsibility": "Sharpens raw or product-like vision candidates into future-state ambitions"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "rawVisionCandidate",
        "originalValue": "",
        "adjustedValue": "Digital books become portable and instantly accessible.",
        "reason": "The original candidate is retained for traceability before sharpening.",
        "ruleApplied": "preserve raw vision candidate",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Vision Shaper",
          "internalName": "Supernanny",
          "responsibility": "Sharpens raw or product-like vision candidates into future-state ambitions"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "sharpenedVisionCandidate",
        "originalValue": "",
        "adjustedValue": "Every reader can access any book instantly, anywhere.",
        "reason": "The Brain inferred a stronger user/world outcome future-state candidate.",
        "ruleApplied": "sharpen product-object future state",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Vision Shaper",
          "internalName": "Supernanny",
          "responsibility": "Sharpens raw or product-like vision candidates into future-state ambitions"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "visionCandidate",
        "originalValue": "Digital books become portable and instantly accessible.",
        "adjustedValue": "Every reader can access any book instantly, anywhere.",
        "reason": "Use the strongest available future-state formulation for follow-up and final outputs.",
        "ruleApplied": "promote sharpened vision candidate",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Vision Shaper",
          "internalName": "Supernanny",
          "responsibility": "Sharpens raw or product-like vision candidates into future-state ambitions"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "readyForSummary",
        "adjustedValue": true,
        "reason": "Summary readiness is based on core strategy ingredients and does not require optional naming, positioning or evidence fields.",
        "ruleApplied": "apply readyForSummary gate",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Readiness Controller",
          "internalName": "The Rock",
          "responsibility": "Controls summary/output readiness gates"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "readyForOutputs",
        "adjustedValue": false,
        "reason": "Extraction can produce a strong vision candidate, but the user has not confirmed it yet.",
        "ruleApplied": "block outputs until future-state confirmation",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Readiness Controller",
          "internalName": "The Rock",
          "responsibility": "Controls summary/output readiness gates"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "needsFollowUpBeforeVision",
        "adjustedValue": true,
        "reason": "A strong but unconfirmed vision candidate blocks final outputs, not the strategy summary.",
        "ruleApplied": "separate summary and output gates",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Readiness Controller",
          "internalName": "The Rock",
          "responsibility": "Controls summary/output readiness gates"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "recommendedNextQuestion",
        "originalValue": "",
        "adjustedValue": "Is the bigger future that every reader can access any book instantly, anywhere?",
        "reason": "Vision mode asks the highest-priority future-state question first.",
        "ruleApplied": "prioritise vision-critical follow-up",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Follow-up Question Generator",
          "internalName": "Louis Theroux",
          "responsibility": "Asks the single most useful next question"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "visionModeSystemNote",
        "originalValue": "",
        "adjustedValue": "Technical, commercial, naming, delivery and derived-output unknowns were saved for later and not used as Vision Brain follow-up questions.",
        "reason": "Later-mode unknowns are retained but not used as Vision mode questions.",
        "ruleApplied": "save later unknowns without blocking Vision mode",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Mode & Safety Rules",
          "internalName": "Arnold J. Rimmer",
          "responsibility": "Blocks premature pricing, API, technical and mode-breaking rabbit holes"
        }
      }
    ],
    "followUpAdjustments": [
      {
        "field": "skippedUnknownsForLater",
        "adjustedValue": [
          "product name",
          "pricing model",
          "technical implementation"
        ],
        "reason": "Later-mode unknowns should not drive Vision mode follow-up questions.",
        "ruleApplied": "save later unknowns",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Mode & Safety Rules",
          "internalName": "Arnold J. Rimmer",
          "responsibility": "Blocks premature pricing, API, technical and mode-breaking rabbit holes"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "visionModeSystemNote",
        "adjustedValue": "Technical, commercial, naming, delivery and derived-output unknowns were saved for later and not used as Vision Brain follow-up questions.",
        "reason": "The trace should explain why some unknowns were skipped.",
        "ruleApplied": "explain skipped unknowns",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Mode & Safety Rules",
          "internalName": "Arnold J. Rimmer",
          "responsibility": "Blocks premature pricing, API, technical and mode-breaking rabbit holes"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "readyForSummary",
        "originalValue": false,
        "adjustedValue": true,
        "reason": "Follow-up readiness must preserve the summary gate.",
        "ruleApplied": "preserve readyForSummary",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Readiness Controller",
          "internalName": "The Rock",
          "responsibility": "Controls summary/output readiness gates"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "question",
        "originalValue": "What APIs does it integrate with?",
        "adjustedValue": "Is the bigger future that every reader can access any book instantly, anywhere?",
        "reason": "The desired future-state candidate must be confirmed or sharpened before final outputs.",
        "ruleApplied": "prioritise future-state confirmation",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Follow-up Question Generator",
          "internalName": "Louis Theroux",
          "responsibility": "Asks the single most useful next question"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "targetIngredient",
        "originalValue": "technical implementation",
        "adjustedValue": "desiredFutureState",
        "reason": "The future-state vision is the current blocker.",
        "ruleApplied": "target desiredFutureState",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Follow-up Question Generator",
          "internalName": "Louis Theroux",
          "responsibility": "Asks the single most useful next question"
        }
      }
    ],
    "stopConditionAdjustments": [
      {
        "field": "skippedUnknownsForLater",
        "adjustedValue": [
          "product name",
          "pricing model",
          "technical implementation"
        ],
        "reason": "Later-mode unknowns should not drive Vision mode follow-up questions.",
        "ruleApplied": "save later unknowns",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Mode & Safety Rules",
          "internalName": "Arnold J. Rimmer",
          "responsibility": "Blocks premature pricing, API, technical and mode-breaking rabbit holes"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "visionModeSystemNote",
        "adjustedValue": "Technical, commercial, naming, delivery and derived-output unknowns were saved for later and not used as Vision Brain follow-up questions.",
        "reason": "The trace should explain why some unknowns were skipped.",
        "ruleApplied": "explain skipped unknowns",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Mode & Safety Rules",
          "internalName": "Arnold J. Rimmer",
          "responsibility": "Blocks premature pricing, API, technical and mode-breaking rabbit holes"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "question",
        "originalValue": "What pricing model are you considering?",
        "adjustedValue": "",
        "reason": "Core vision ingredients are ready.",
        "ruleApplied": "stop asking when readyForOutputs is true",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Readiness Controller",
          "internalName": "The Rock",
          "responsibility": "Controls summary/output readiness gates"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "whyThisMatters",
        "originalValue": "This may affect the business model.",
        "adjustedValue": "Core vision ingredients are ready. Generate the strategy summary and outputs next.",
        "reason": "The user should move forward instead of answering optional questions.",
        "ruleApplied": "guide next action after readyForOutputs stop",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Readiness Controller",
          "internalName": "The Rock",
          "responsibility": "Controls summary/output readiness gates"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "targetIngredient",
        "originalValue": "pricing",
        "adjustedValue": "",
        "reason": "No Vision-mode follow-up is needed.",
        "ruleApplied": "clear target ingredient after readyForOutputs stop",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Readiness Controller",
          "internalName": "The Rock",
          "responsibility": "Controls summary/output readiness gates"
        }
      },
      {
        "field": "readyForOutputs",
        "originalValue": false,
        "adjustedValue": true,
        "reason": "Final outputs are ready.",
        "ruleApplied": "apply readyForOutputs gate",
        "component": {
          "formalName": "Readiness Controller",
          "internalName": "The Rock",
          "responsibility": "Controls summary/output readiness gates"
        }
      }
    ],
    "outputAdjustments": []
  }
}